Free Consultation: (219) 228-8886Tap to Call This Lawyer
Andrew L. Bennett

Andrew L. Bennett

Bennett & Catsadimas, P.C.
  • Criminal Law, DUI & DWI, Traffic Tickets ...
  • Indiana
Review This Lawyer
Lawyer Rating and Reviews
Legal Knowledge
Legal Analysis
Communication Skills
Ethics and Professionalism
Paul Stanko
Paul Stanko June 16, 2018
Rating: 10 Lawyer Rating - 10 out of 10
During years of interaction with Andrew Bennett, I have been impressed with his honesty and competence.
Client Reviews
D. C. February 18, 2024
OWI case dismissed I made a stupid decision and Andrew patiently fought for me for 3 years to dismiss an OWI case. He is extremely affordable and makes you feel like your case is his first priority from beginning to end. Couldn’t be happier with how he treated me as a client. He is very respectful, knowledgeable, understanding, and shows with his actions that he cares and wants the best for each of his clients. I’d recommend him to anyone.
Claimed Lawyer ProfileQ&ALII GoldSocial Media

I am an experienced criminal trial attorney, with over 22 years practicing law, including felony trials for Reckless Homicide. The majority of those years were spent as a deputy prosecuting attorney where I concentrated on OWI cases including OWI Causing Death cases.

In my capacity as a deputy prosecuting attorney I would routinely go to crash scenes at all hours of the day or night. Many times throughout the year I would conduct training for law enforcement officers. This has provided me with a keen insight into and knowledge of the criminal justice system.

This passion to do my best and put the hours needed into a case is now brought to defending my clients in Northwest Indiana including the counties of Lake, Porter, La Porte, St. Joseph, Newton, Jasper, Starke and Marshall in a variety of criminal cases including misdemeanors and complex felonies.

I rely upon my honesty and integrity, presenting the facts in a straight forward manner. I strive to maintain a strong rapport with my clients, other legal professionals and the bench. I would like to put my knowledge, experience & dedication to work for you.

Practice Areas
    Criminal Law
    Criminal Appeals, Drug Crimes, Expungement, Fraud, Gun Crimes, Internet Crimes, Sex Crimes, Theft, Violent Crimes
    DUI & DWI
    Traffic Tickets
    Suspended License
    Domestic Violence
    Domestic Violence Criminal Defense, Domestic Violence Restraining Orders
    White Collar Crime
Additional Practice Areas
  • Specialized Driving Privileges
  • Expungements
  • Free Consultation
  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • Rates, Retainers and Additional Information
    I do offer flexible payment plans that work with your budget.
Jurisdictions Admitted to Practice
Placeholder image for jurisdictions.
  • English: Spoken, Written
Professional Experience
Valparaiso University School of Law
J.D. | Law
Placeholder image for education.
Ball State University
B.S. (1994) | Political Science, Psychology, Business
Ball State University Logo
Client's Choice Award
Professional Associations
Indiana State Bar  # 20788-45
Placeholder image for professional associations.
Lake County Bar Association
- Current
Activities: Criminal Defense section
Placeholder image for professional associations.
Porter County Bar Association
- Current
Placeholder image for professional associations.
American Inns of Court, Calumet Council
Master of the Bench
- Current
Placeholder image for professional associations.
Speaking Engagements
Prosecutor Perspective in OWI cases and substance abuse treatment, Fall Conference, Nashville, IN
Panel discussion for Introduction to Courts, Ivy Tech College
Panel discussion on Criminal Justice System, the role of the Police, Prosecutor and Defense Attorney, Criminal Law class
Ivy Tech College
Websites & Blogs
Andrew L. Bennett's Website Profile
Bennett & Catsadimas, P.C. Website
Legal Answers
681 Questions Answered
Q. First time level 6 felony , what amount of jailtime. Or can.probation be an alternative to jail.
A: A level 6 felony has a penalty range of 6 months to 2 1/2 years in jail or prison. However, the incarceration for the person can be suspended and placed on probation. Rehab will not lessen the penalty per se but is a mitigating factor in determining the appropriate sentence.
Q. Should i plead guilty? no contest? or ask for infraction deferral?
A: Pleading guilty will add significant points to your record. Also, a no contest is really a plea of guilty in disguise, same effect. If the prosecutor offers an infraction deferral, that would keep the conviction and points off your record. If they do not offer the deferral, then you should consult with an attorney, he/she may be able to get you a better deal than pleading to the charge, even if it costs a few hundred more than paying the ticket, in the long run with insurance, etc. it will be money well spent.
Q. In 2020, I got a warning for speeding in Indiana and today I got a speeding ticket due to that warning.
A: If the ticket was filed more than 2 years after the infraction offense date then the State has blown the statute of limitations and the case should be dismissed.
View More Answers
Contact & Map
Bennett & Catsadimas, P.C.
205 E Jefferson Street
Valparaiso, IN 46383
Telephone: (219) 228-8886
Fax: (219) 228-8626
Monday: 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday: 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Wednesday: 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday: 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday: 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed (Today)
Toggle tool

There are no recently viewed profiles.

There are no saved profiles.

There are no profiles to compare.