Lawyer Rating and Reviews
Legal Knowledge
5.0/5.0
Legal Analysis
5.0/5.0
Communication Skills
5.0/5.0
Ethics and Professionalism
5.0/5.0
Melinda McElheny
Melinda McElheny June 11, 2024
Rating: 10 Lawyer Rating - 10 out of 10
This attorney has very high emotional intelligence and wisdom. Her courtroom skills are strong and I often find myself trying to emulate her in court. She is great at negotiation and collaborating with other attorneys, but she will take the gloves off in court to advocate for her client. She is fair and honest with clients, unafraid to tell them things they may not want to hear but need to hear. She can be very compassionate and warm, or aggressive and ballsy, when the situation calls for it. View More
Q. How do you know this lawyer?
  • Friend
  • Other

Local colleague for twelve years and counting

Q. In the cases you were involved in with this attorney, which of the following apply?
  • Same Client
  • Different Client, Same Side of Case
  • Opposing Client

I have worked with this attorney in multi-party settings as both opposing and same side counsel, as casual consultants in various types of cases, and in same courtrooms-different cases observations.

Q. When did you work with this lawyer?
From June 2012 and counting
Q. Was this lawyer an effective advocate/counselor and why?
Yes

This lawyer is insightful, careful, and direct. She is direct with her clients and with other attorneys. She is well-respected by other attorneys as someone who works hard for her clients and against other attorneys without sacrificing personal or professional ethics or bending to social pressures. She uses multiple resources and experience to find solutions to problems for her clients.

Q. Please rate this lawyer on the following:

Legal Knowledge: Excellent

This attorney has extensive knowledge and experience in many areas of law. When she does not know an area of law, she finds resources to learn and get up to speed to help her clients.

Legal Analysis: Excellent

This attorney uses both knowledge of the law and instincts gained from experience to predict how a case should go versus how it will likely go. This means she can be very realistic with her clients and work successfully with other attorneys in negotiations.

Communication Skills: Excellent

This attorney is direct and strong in her communication without being a "typical" lawyer personality. She is kind when needed, no-nonsense and forthright, and does not shy away from difficult conversations with clients or colleagues.

Ethics and Professionalism: Excellent

This attorney seeks to do the right thing and checks herself frequently to make sure she is performing ethically. She is sought after as a coworker by other attorneys in many types of cases because she is professional and easy to work with--you can count on her to do her job.

Q. For which practice area(s) would you recommend this lawyer?
Criminal, family (domestic or CINC), other dispute resolution areas
Q. Which of the following skills does this lawyer possess?
  • Client Relations
  • Collaboration
  • Dispute Resolution
  • Emotional Intelligence
  • Litigation
  • Mediation
  • Negotiation
  • Oral Argument
  • Problem Solving
  • Pro Bono and Community Services
  • Trials

This attorney may possess additional skills that I have not had the opportunity to assess in our interactions. She has superior emotional intelligence and problem solving skills. She performs well in trial or litigation-activity situations. She is masterful in portraying logic and reason to judges and juries.

Q. Please provide any additional comments about this lawyer
I have tried to get this lawyer to join me in practice for years now because she is so great to work with. She is one who cares deeply about solving client problems, but she can do this without alienating opposing attorneys.
Q. I would recommend this lawyer to my family and friends
Yes